stats for wordpress

Are you on Facebook?

Would you please click "like" in the box to your right, or

Visit us on Facebook!

Judge Rules One of America’s Most Vocal Anti-LGBT Catholics Must Testify About Abuse

by Casey Michel on February 18, 2014

in Bigotry Watch,Casey Michel,News,Religion

Post image for Judge Rules One of America’s Most Vocal Anti-LGBT Catholics Must Testify About Abuse

On Sunday afternoon, Ramsey County District Judge John Van de North confirmed that Minneapolis Archbishop John Nienstedt, one of the nation’s most vocal and vociferous Catholic anti-LGBT voices, must testify about covering up child abuse within the church in Minnesota. Sunday’s ruling, which mirrored his decision early last week, came in response to the Twin Cities archdiocese’s appeal to stay the testimony.

Former Vicar General Kevin McDonough, who recently resigned in light of the cover-up, will also be forced to testify before March 13. The judge also reconfirmed his ruling that the church must turn in a list of all priests accused of child and sexual abuse since 2004, though such names will remain under seal. The archdiocese released a partial list in late 2013, but had refused to release the entire list.

The church’s failed attempt at a stay represented, according to Minnesota Public Radio, a “more aggressive legal approach” than those yet fielded. It also offered its most public legal failure to date in the state, and it remains unclear whether any mechanism for appeal remains.

The ruling stands as a boon to both those seeking recourse for decades of sex abuse within the Catholic Church, as well as those who know Nienstedt for his history of outspoken bigotry. While his anti-LGBT views aren’t as prominent as Cardinal Timothy Dolan, Nienstedt arguably carries the most acidic views among high-ranking American Catholics.

Nienstedt’s beliefs came to a head in the lead-up to the state’s 2012 anti-same-sex marriage amendment, which the archbishop both spearheaded and helped fund through the church’s charity arm. (This, while numerous churches in his diocese were closing due to a lack of financial support.) After spending years graphically detailing scenes from Brokeback Mountain in church bulletins, staking that those who “actively encourage … homosexual acts” are committing “mortal sin,” and mailing — without asking — 400,000 anti-gay marriage DVDs to the state’s Catholics, the archbishop tossed the full weight of his organization behind a state amendment defining marriage as a union between one man and one woman.

The amendment, of course, failed, and but a few months later Minnesota became the 12th state to legalize same-sex marriage in the US. Not long after, MPR began unearthing claims and documentation detailing the decades of sex abuse committed by Minensota priests – and the subsequent cover-up from Nienstedt and the two archbishops coming prior. Numerous priests were reshuffled, promoted, or placed on paid leave without attendant reporting to local authorities. As MPR’s investigative work continued, a boy accused Nienstedt of improper touching during a Confirmation ceremony. The archbishop stepped aside temporarily while the investigation unfurled. He has not been seen in public since. As such, not only will the forthcoming testimony provide legal means to examine the decades of cover-up, but it will force Nienstedt to speak on an issue that, unlike LGBT rights, he has remained resoundingly silent on recently.

Casey Michel HeadshotCasey Michel is a graduate student at Columbia University, and former Peace Corps Kazakhstan volunteer. His writing has appeared in The Atlantic, Slate, and Talking Points Memo, and he has contributed multiple long-form investigations to Minneapolis’s City Pages and the Houston Press. You can follow him on Twitter.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...


We invite you to sign up for our new mailing list, and subscribe to The New Civil Rights Movement via email or RSS.

Also, please like us on Facebook, and follow us on Twitter!


LOrion February 18, 2014 at 1:57 pm

YES YES YES! Sharing!

xenubarb February 18, 2014 at 3:42 pm

What does it say about a man who obsesses endlessly about sexual acts between consenting adults while ignoring sexual abuse of a priest and a nonconsenting minor?

Nothing good.

Mykelbarber February 19, 2014 at 2:27 am

Every single official of the Catholic Church should be rounded up by police, stripped of US citizenship, charged with failing to register as Agents of a Foreign Government, and renditioned to the Vatican never to be seen or heard from again.

sdfrenchie February 19, 2014 at 6:00 pm

So good to see this happening. It's one thing for two consenting adults to want equal rights that should have been theirs to begin with, and another when adult men are so rotten to the core that they would even touch a child improperly with one finger, let alone have sex with one. If they're so damned horny, why don't they screw another Priest (or whatever rank). Abuse of children in this country is serious and far too frequent as it is without a church member putting a child in such a horrifying situation. Thankfully I never became a full-fledged Catholic, or any other Christian faith because I saw the hypocrisy at an early age and walked away from it all with a clear conscience.

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: