Sanders New Ad ‘America’ Praised For Being ‘Warm,’ Panned For Being ‘Very White’
A new ad featuring Simon and Garfunkel is being both praised and panned.Â
A new Bernie Sanders ad released Thursday is being lauded as a breath of fresh air in an increasingly hostile political climate, and panned for what some are saying is a glaring lack of diversity. The 60-second spot, “America,” features the familiar Simon and Garfunkel 1968 hit by the the same name.
The Sanders campaign posted the video to YouTube, and on Twitter wrote, “This campaign is not about Bernie Sanders, Hillary Clinton, or Donald Trump. This campaign is about you.”
This campaign is not about Bernie Sanders, Hillary Clinton, or Donald Trump. This campaign is about you. https://t.co/GnGYyU6rl6
— Bernie Sanders (@BernieSanders) January 21, 2016
The New York Times wrote that the ad “seeks to remind his supporters how far he, and they, have come — and to inspire them anew to caucus for him on Feb. 1.” Calling the ad’s message “hope and inclusiveness,” it says “the ad takes the microphone out of the candidate’s hand and turns it around: His campaign, it signals, is about the people who are supporting him.”
“Minorities are given prominence, presumably to address Mr. Sanders’s difficulties in attracting support among blacks and Hispanics,” the Times notes.
But some are taking issue with that claim, including prominent New York Times opinion writer Charles M. Blow, who took to Twitter to share his thoughts:
Bernie Sanders, and Simon and Garfunkel, Put Focus on Voters https://t.co/3SbSmEY0RB <— I would have liked even more diversity in this…
— Charles M. Blow (@CharlesMBlow) January 21, 2016
Calling it “very powerful,” Matthew Yglesias at Vox writes, “the striking thing about this ad, as Jamelle Bouie hints, is that especially for a Democrat it’s very white.”
“There are a handful of nonwhite faces, but you are looking overwhelmingly at white people often in very white settings like northern New England. The soundtrack is very white.”
The “hint” is a tweet Bouie posted, saying, “This is a very good add that also highlights the problem Sanders has to solve to win.”
David A. Graham at The Atlantic calls it “extremely positive” and “a pretty great spot, with lots of warm fuzzies,” but says, “ it’s hard not to notice how white the ad is—I counted perhaps half a dozen people of color in the spot.”
The images and messaging in an ad like this are never accidental, so let’s try to parse out what they mean. First, the ad is extremely positive—it’s all smiling faces and happy children, hardworking farmers and cheering crowds. That matches with Sanders’s vow, mostly kept, to run a positive campaign. Second, the ad is heavily steeped in classic Americana. In particular, the ad leans on rural imagery, fitting with it primary audience Iowa and New Hampshire. The message might also blunt the attempt by some allies of Hillary Clinton to tar Sanders as a socialist. See, look? He’s as American as mom and apple pie.
Others on Twitter shared similar feelings:
Bernie Sanders new “America” ad is packed to the rim with so many white people I thought I was watching a Trump ad. C’mon Diversity!
— (•◡•) HillBro (@HillBroYo) January 21, 2016
Bernie’s beautiful new ad is overwhelmingly white, and that could be problematic soon https://t.co/v6vRgre1wY
— Joe Cozza (@joecozza14) January 21, 2016
Obs abt Sanders’ ad: Non-rally footage lacks racial diversity… I’m wondering why, given Qs abt Afr Am polling. https://t.co/8lCk9OgT5y
— Chrissie Thompson (@CThompsonENQ) January 21, 2016
Other problem with that Sanders ad…it’s incredibly white on every level. The post IA/NH Democrat primary…isn’t.
— Drew McCoy (@DrewMTips) January 21, 2016
Bernie Sanders’ America “…it’s hard not to notice how white the ad is…” https://t.co/8msMZm2y5B
— M.G. (@mfiiiiive) January 21, 2016
I #FeelTheBern, but it’s a big problem that just about every scene in this new “America” ad shows only white people. https://t.co/dQXhilH9Rc
— Jack Delehanty (@jack_dele) January 21, 2016
The Bernie Sanders ad pretty much captures it all. Rousing, positive, super-white. https://t.co/FUUYhF9ouz
— Jody Avirgan (@jodyavirgan) January 21, 2016
Wow. Bernie Sanders’ “America” ad is 99% white people. I guess I shouldn’t be surprised, but didn’t anyone making it notice?
— ProfNita (@ProfNita) January 21, 2016
People criticize you for being out of touch w/ minorities so you make an ad full of white people. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ https://t.co/4TnDiVMUuU
— Peter Krupa (@peterkrupa) January 21, 2016
This ad is everything that I hate about Sanders. Old song, misinterpreted, pix so white, all about him, issue-free. https://t.co/oVERJMx49Y
— Diane Curtis (@DianeCurtis50) January 21, 2016
People are raving about new #BernieSanders ad, but still — I see white people. https://t.co/4j5bdmbNWY
— Paul Singer (@singernews) January 21, 2016
Again, here’s the ad. What do you think?
Â
Image: Screenshot via Bernie 2016/YouTube
 Â
Enjoy this piece?
… then let us make a small request. The New Civil Rights Movement depends on readers like you to meet our ongoing expenses and continue producing quality progressive journalism. Three Silicon Valley giants consume 70 percent of all online advertising dollars, so we need your help to continue doing what we do.
NCRM is independent. You won’t find mainstream media bias here. From unflinching coverage of religious extremism, to spotlighting efforts to roll back our rights, NCRM continues to speak truth to power. America needs independent voices like NCRM to be sure no one is forgotten.
Every reader contribution, whatever the amount, makes a tremendous difference. Help ensure NCRM remains independent long into the future. Support progressive journalism with a one-time contribution to NCRM, or click here to become a subscriber. Thank you. Click here to donate by check.