stats for wordpress

Are you on Facebook?

Would you please click "like" in the box to your right, or

Visit us on Facebook!

We Are Winning

by Jennifer Vanasco on March 26, 2013

in Jennifer Vanasco,Marriage,News,Op-Ed,Politics

Post image for We Are Winning

Today, standing outside the Supreme Court on this historic day, one thing became clear: We are winning.

We might not win the battle over Prop 8, of course, or over DOMA (though I suspect that the Justices will reach a narrow decision that both gives marriage equality back to California and mandates that the federal government recognize gay marriage in states where it has been legalized), but we were are absolutely, without a doubt, no question winning the war of public opinion.

How do I know?

When I was reporting today for a story about what happened outside the oral arguments for Prop 8, not one person I spoke with who was pro-marriage equality refused to give their names. Not one. They gave me their first name, their last name, their email address, their phone number. They told me where they worked, where they were from.

On the other hand, most people on the other side refused to give me a first name. They didn’t want me to take their picture. One woman, holding up a sign that said, “Kids Deserve a Mom and a Dad,” wouldn’t answer when I asked her why she was there, or why this case was important to her. Instead, she just said, “I really don’t want to say anything other than what’s on the sign.”

This is extraordinary.

It’s extraordinary, because when I first started covering LGBT issues 20 years ago, it was tough to get a gay person in a crowd to give their name. They were worried (and rightfully so) that they would lose their jobs, their friends, their families. The only names you could count on getting were from people who were “professionally gay” – those who had outed themselves publicly, sometimes in spectacular ways, or who worked for a gay organization.

Now the situation is reversed. I suspect that the anti-marriage equality people who wouldn’t give me their names were embarrassed. They know their opinion might make others think less of them. It could damage their credibility and respect in their families or offices or among their neighbors.

It is no longer shameful to be gay. Now it is only shameful to be anti-gay.

That means that no matter what the Supreme Court says, no matter how this very important decision turns out, we will have marriage equality in the long run. There is no telling what this divided Court will do. But in the court of public opinion, we have already won.

Images by The New Civil Rights Movement’s Tanya Domi, taken today outside the Supreme Court

Jennifer Vanasco is an award-winning writer who specializes in national electoral politics and LGBT and women’s issues. She is the Minority Reports columnist for Columbia Journalism Review, analyzing how the mainstream media covers social minority issues and the former Editor in Chief of MTV Network’s gay news and politics website For 15 years, she wrote a nationally-syndicated newspaper column on gay and lesbian politics and life. Her work has appeared in the Village Voice, Chicago Tribune, Huffington Post and WNYC public radio’s politics blog. She lives in Manhattan with her wife Jenny. Tweet her at @JenniferVanasco.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...


We invite you to sign up for our new mailing list, and subscribe to The New Civil Rights Movement via email or RSS.

Also, please like us on Facebook, and follow us on Twitter!

{ 1 comment }

SmartiPants50 March 26, 2013 at 7:05 pm

I've read the transcript of the first day, and I agree with you. We can look for more movement now that the Supreme Court has finally started the process of reviewing this case. Most negativity I read in your post, about people not giving their names, proves that they have to live with what they stand for in their community. Today was another plateau achieved. Stay tuned! :)

Comments on this entry are closed.

{ 1 trackback }

Previous post:

Next post: